
Get The Field Report
Canada’s rate news, new articles and Bank of Canada moves, every two weeks.
Cashable and redeemable guaranteed investment certificates (GICs) offer Canadian savers an alternative to traditional GICs, combining the certainty of a fixed interest rate with the ability to access their money before maturity. However, that flexibility generally comes at the expense of a lower return, making it worth comparing these products against high-interest savings accounts (HISAs).
With interest rates varying considerably between financial institutions, choosing the right savings product involves more than finding the highest advertised rate. The length of the investment, withdrawal restrictions, and potential changes in interest rates can all influence how much an investor ultimately earns.
As of November 15, 2026, the highest nationally available one-year redeemable GIC rate is 3.00%, matching the leading everyday high-interest savings account rates. By comparison, the highest one-year non-redeemable GIC offers 4.05%, a difference of $105 in annual interest on a $10,000 investment.
While these differences may appear relatively modest, they become more significant over longer investment periods. Understanding how GICs and savings accounts compare can help Canadians determine which option offers the most appropriate balance of returns, accessibility, and interest rate certainty.
Understanding the Differences Between GICs and High-Interest Savings Accounts
GICs and high-interest savings accounts both provide opportunities to earn interest on deposited funds, but they differ in how returns are determined and how readily money can be accessed.
- A high-interest savings account allows account holders to deposit and withdraw funds without committing to a fixed investment term. Interest rates are generally variable, meaning financial institutions can adjust them in response to market conditions, changes in monetary policy, or their own deposit requirements. While this flexibility makes savings accounts particularly useful for emergency funds and short-term savings, the advertised interest rate is not guaranteed to remain unchanged.
- A non-redeemable GIC, by comparison, provides a guaranteed interest rate over a specified term, typically ranging from one to five years. Investors agree to keep their funds deposited until maturity in exchange for greater certainty about their returns. Because financial institutions can rely on those deposits remaining in place, non-redeemable GICs generally offer higher interest rates than flexible alternatives.
- Cashable and redeemable GICs fall between these two options. They provide a fixed interest rate for the investment term while permitting withdrawals under specified conditions. Although they offer greater flexibility than non-redeemable GICs, their withdrawal provisions can be more restrictive than those of a traditional savings account.
These differences are particularly important when comparing products with similar interest rates. A savings account paying 3.00% today may offer a different return over the next twelve months if the institution changes its rate. A one-year GIC advertising 3.00%, meanwhile, provides a fixed contractual rate, although the amount of interest earned may be reduced if the investment is redeemed before maturity.
Cashable vs. Redeemable GICs
Although cashable and redeemable GICs are often grouped together, the terms can describe products with different withdrawal conditions.
- Cashable GICs generally allow investors to withdraw their funds after an initial holding period while retaining interest earned according to the product’s terms.
- Redeemable GICs permit early withdrawals but may apply a reduced interest rate, an early redemption penalty, or other restrictions.
- Non-redeemable GICs generally require investors to keep their funds deposited until maturity, with limited exceptions.
There is no universal set of withdrawal conditions that applies to every institution. A GIC advertising 3.00%, for example, may pay that rate only when held to maturity, with a reduced rate applying if the investment is redeemed after six months. Investors should therefore compare minimum holding periods, interest calculations, early redemption provisions, and restrictions on partial withdrawals alongside the advertised interest rate. These details can significantly affect the actual return, particularly when access to funds is an important consideration.
Comparing Current GIC and High-Interest Savings Rates in Canada
Current rates provide a useful starting point for evaluating whether a cashable or redeemable GIC offers an advantage over a high-interest savings account.
As of November 15, 2026, the highest nationally available one-year redeemable GIC and the leading everyday high-interest savings accounts both offer 3.00%. Non-redeemable GICs provide higher returns, while products marketed specifically as cashable may offer lower rates than some redeemable alternatives.
| Financial institution and product | Interest rate | Annual interest on $10,000 |
|---|---|---|
| KEB Hana Bank Canada – 1-year redeemable GIC | 3.00% | $300 |
| Oaken Financial – Savings Account | 3.00% | $300 |
| Wealth One Bank of Canada – Savings Account | 3.00% | $300 |
| SBI Canada Bank – 1-year cashable GIC | 2.40% | $240 |
| Wealth One Bank of Canada – 1-year non-redeemable GIC | 4.05% | $405 |
Rates as of November 15, 2026, based on products available nationally and a $10,000 deposit. Illustrative interest amounts assume the stated rates apply for a full year, without compounding. Savings account rates are variable, and actual GIC returns depend on the applicable product terms.
At these rates, investors choosing between a one-year redeemable GIC and a competitive everyday savings account are not receiving additional advertised interest in exchange for accepting withdrawal restrictions. Instead, the main financial advantage of the GIC is the certainty of its contractual rate.
That distinction may be important for investors who expect savings rates to decline or want to know the applicable interest rate in advance. For those who prioritize immediate access to funds, a high-interest savings account offers comparable advertised earnings without the added complexity of GIC redemption conditions.
What the Numbers Tell Us
The highest available rate isn’t necessarily associated with the most suitable savings product.
With both the leading one-year redeemable GIC and everyday high-interest savings accounts offering 3.00%, there is currently no advertised rate premium for choosing the GIC. Investors are effectively deciding between a fixed contractual rate with conditional access to their money and a variable rate with greater withdrawal flexibility.
The GIC becomes more attractive if savings rates decline during the year, while the savings account may provide an advantage if rates increase. For investors who expect to need their funds on short notice, the simplicity of a savings account is another consideration that the interest rate alone does not capture.
How Do Big-Bank Savings Rates Compare?
Although the most competitive high-interest savings accounts currently offer rates around 3.00%, the returns available through standard savings products at Canada’s major banks can be considerably lower.
RateHunter’s November 15 comparison identifies the following advertised rates:
- RBC High Interest eSavings: 0.65%
- TD ePremium Savings: 0.55% on a $10,000 balance
- Scotiabank HISA: 1.75%
The difference is substantial. On a $10,000 balance, an account earning 3.00% generates $300 in annual interest, assuming the rate remains unchanged. At 0.55%, that same balance earns just $55, representing a $245 difference over twelve months.
For Canadians holding significant savings in lower-interest accounts, moving funds to a more competitive institution may provide a larger improvement in returns than switching between different types of GICs.
Promotional savings offers can alter these comparisons, particularly when institutions introduce temporary rates to attract new deposits. CIBC, for example, has a promotional savings rate of 5.00% listed in the November 15 comparison, exceeding the leading one-year non-redeemable GIC rate. However, promotional offers frequently include restrictions relating to new customers, eligible deposits, maximum balances, or the length of the promotional period. Once the introductory rate expires, the account may revert to a significantly lower standard rate.
A meaningful comparison should account for the total interest expected over the intended savings period, rather than relying exclusively on the highest advertised promotional rate.
What the Numbers Tell Us
Where you save can matter more than the type of account you choose.
The $245 annual difference between savings accounts paying 0.55% and 3.00% is more than twice the $105 difference between the leading one-year redeemable and non-redeemable GICs in the national comparison.
For Canadians who already have money in a savings account, this suggests that comparing rates across financial institutions may be one of the most effective ways to improve returns without necessarily accepting additional restrictions on access to their funds.
It also highlights the importance of looking beyond familiar banking brands. Competitive deposit rates are not exclusive to Canada’s largest financial institutions, and smaller banks and online savings providers may offer better returns on comparable products.
Do Longer-Term Redeemable GICs Offer Better Returns?
While one-year redeemable GICs currently offer rates comparable to leading everyday savings accounts, the difference begins to widen over longer investment terms.
The highest nationally available flexible GIC rates range from 3.10% for two years to 3.50% for five years, providing a modest premium over today’s leading everyday savings rate of 3.00%.
| GIC term | Highest flexible GIC rate | Additional annual interest vs. 3.00% on $10,000 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 year | 3.00% | $0 |
| 2 years | 3.10% | $10 |
| 3 years | 3.20% | $20 |
| 4 years | 3.35% | $35 |
| 5 years | 3.50% | $50 |
Rates as of November 15, 2026. Differences represent illustrative annual interest at the stated rates, not total returns over the full term. Flexible GIC products may have different redemption conditions.
Moving from a one-year redeemable GIC at 3.00% to a five-year option at 3.50% increases the advertised annual return by half a percentage point. For an investment of $10,000, that represents approximately $50 in additional annual interest before compounding, provided the investment remains eligible for the full advertised rate.
The more significant consideration is the certainty of maintaining that rate over several years. A five-year fixed-rate GIC protects the investor from reductions in its contracted rate during the term, whereas the return on a savings account can fluctuate.
However, longer-term GICs also create a greater commitment. Even when early redemption is permitted, withdrawing funds may result in reduced interest earnings or other limitations. Investors should consider whether they expect to need access to their savings and whether the additional return justifies accepting those conditions.
The Cost of Choosing Flexibility Over a Non-Redeemable GIC
For investors who are confident they will not need access to their money before maturity, non-redeemable GICs can offer a meaningful advantage over cashable and redeemable alternatives.
Across one- to five-year terms, the highest non-redeemable GIC rates currently exceed the leading flexible alternatives by approximately 1.05 to 1.20 percentage points. On a $10,000 investment, that represents an additional $105 to $120 in annual interest before compounding.
| Term | Highest non-redeemable GIC | Highest flexible GIC | Annual interest difference on $10,000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 year | 4.05% | 3.00% | $105 |
| 2 years | 4.30% | 3.10% | $120 |
| 3 years | 4.40% | 3.20% | $120 |
| 4 years | 4.45% | 3.35% | $110 |
| 5 years | 4.55% | 3.50% | $105 |
Rates as of November 15, 2026. Annual differences are illustrative and exclude compounding. The flexible category includes products with different redemption provisions, including partially cashable products.
Over longer investment periods, these differences become more substantial as interest accumulates. A $10,000 investment earning 4.55% annually over five years would grow to approximately $12,492, assuming annual compounding. At 3.50%, the same investment would grow to approximately $11,877, a difference of roughly $615 in total earnings.
While this comparison illustrates the potential financial benefit of committing funds for the full term, it does not account for the value of accessing those funds earlier if circumstances change.
What the Numbers Tell Us
Flexibility has a measurable cost, particularly over longer investment periods.
The approximately $615 difference in earnings over five years illustrates the financial trade-off between the highest non-redeemable and flexible GIC rates. For investors who have sufficient emergency savings and a clearly defined investment timeline, committing funds to a non-redeemable GIC may provide a worthwhile increase in guaranteed returns.
However, the additional interest needs to be considered alongside the consequences of restricted access. An investor who unexpectedly needs their savings before maturity may face considerably greater financial inconvenience than the additional earnings would justify.
Rather than selecting a GIC based solely on its interest rate, investors should consider how much of their savings they can realistically commit for the entire term. Maintaining a portion in an accessible savings account while investing longer-term funds in non-redeemable GICs may provide a more practical balance.
Provincial Credit Unions May Offer More Competitive Rates
National GIC comparisons do not always capture the most competitive products available to Canadian savers. Provincial credit unions frequently offer attractive deposit rates, although membership and residency requirements can limit availability.
Unlike banks that generally accept customers across Canada, many credit unions primarily serve residents of specific provinces or communities. As a result, the highest accessible GIC rate may depend partly on where an investor lives.
RateHunter’s November 15 data identifies several regional products that exceed the leading nationally available flexible GIC rates.
| Province | Financial institution | Product term | Advertised rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ontario | HMECU | 1-year cashable | 3.75% |
| Ontario | DUCA | 5-year redeemable | 3.60% |
| Saskatchewan | Bruno Savings & Credit Union | 1-year redeemable | 3.75% |
| Manitoba | Fusion Credit Union | 5-year redeemable | 3.60% |
These products demonstrate the potential advantage of including regional institutions when comparing deposit rates. For example, an eligible Ontario investor considering HMECU’s one-year cashable GIC at 3.75% could earn an additional $75 annually on a $10,000 investment compared with a nationally available redeemable GIC paying 3.00%, assuming the advertised rates apply throughout the year.
However, the products may have different redemption provisions, and eligibility requirements should be confirmed before making a direct comparison.
A Notable Alternative: Hubert Financial
Hubert Financial offers a one-year quarterly term deposit that provides a different approach to balancing returns and liquidity.
Rather than requiring funds to remain invested for the entire year, the product permits withdrawals at specified quarterly intervals while allowing investors to retain interest already paid. The advertised quarterly interest rates increase from 3.20% to 4.70%, producing an average annual rate of 3.95% when the investment is held for the full term.
That compares favourably with the leading nationally available one-year non-redeemable GIC rate of 4.05%, while providing opportunities to access funds at three, six, or nine months.
The timing of withdrawals is an important consideration. Investors who withdraw after the first quarter receive the applicable first-quarter rate rather than the full-year average, and withdrawals are subject to the product’s specified conditions.
Hubert Financial is available to eligible members across Canada, excluding Quebec, making it a potentially relevant option for investors who want a competitive rate without committing their funds for an uninterrupted twelve-month period.
What the Numbers Tell Us
Some of the most competitive flexible GIC rates are available outside traditional national banking products.
Eligible investors in Ontario and Saskatchewan can currently access selected one-year credit union products paying 3.75%, compared with the leading nationally available redeemable GIC rate of 3.00%. For a $10,000 investment, that difference represents $75 in additional annual interest before compounding.
Hubert Financial’s quarterly term deposit also illustrates how withdrawal structures can influence the value of a product. Its 3.95% average annual rate, when held for the full year, comes close to the leading non-redeemable GIC rate while offering scheduled opportunities to access funds.
These examples suggest that investors may benefit from evaluating a broader range of institutions and product structures rather than limiting their search to familiar banks or conventional GIC categories. However, the highest advertised rate is only one part of the comparison; membership eligibility, redemption provisions, and deposit protection remain essential considerations.
Understanding Deposit Insurance
Deposit protection is another factor worth considering when comparing banks, credit unions, and other financial institutions.
Eligible deposits held at Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation (CDIC) member institutions are protected under federal deposit insurance rules, subject to applicable coverage limits and categories. Provincial credit unions generally operate under separate deposit protection frameworks, with coverage arrangements that vary by jurisdiction.
Investors should confirm which organization insures their deposits, the applicable coverage limits, and whether the particular product qualifies for protection.
For additional information, consult CDIC’s deposit insurance coverage guide.
How Interest Rate Changes Affect the Decision
The relative value of a GIC and a high-interest savings account can change as market interest rates move. While a fixed-rate GIC establishes the applicable rate for its term, a savings account generally pays a variable rate that financial institutions can adjust. This creates different advantages depending on the direction of future interest rates.
If Interest Rates Decline
Declining interest rates can make fixed-rate GICs more attractive, particularly when the contracted rate exceeds the returns available on newly issued products or savings accounts.
For example, an investor who purchases a one-year GIC at 3.00% maintains that contracted rate during the term, provided the investment remains eligible under its conditions. If a comparable savings account subsequently reduces its rate to 2.50%, the GIC would offer a higher return over the remaining period.
This protection becomes more valuable when rates decline significantly or remain lower for an extended period. Longer-term GICs can provide additional certainty by securing a rate for several years, although that benefit comes with a greater commitment of funds.
If Interest Rates Increase
Rising interest rates can favour savings accounts, particularly when financial institutions increase the rates paid on existing deposits.
Investors holding fixed-rate GICs generally continue earning their contracted rates, even when newer GICs or savings accounts offer more competitive returns. Cashable and redeemable GICs may allow investors to withdraw their funds and reinvest at higher rates, but the financial benefit depends on the applicable early redemption conditions.
The Bank of Canada’s October 28, 2026 policy announcement reported an increase in its policy interest rate to 2.50% and indicated that further increases could be necessary.
However, changes in the Bank of Canada’s policy rate do not translate directly into equivalent movements across all savings and GIC products. Individual financial institutions establish their own deposit rates based on funding needs, competition, and broader financial conditions. Rather than attempting to predict future rate movements, investors may benefit from selecting products that align with their savings timelines and tolerance for changing returns.
When Does a Cashable GIC Make Sense?
A cashable or redeemable GIC may be appropriate for investors who want greater certainty about their returns without completely sacrificing the ability to access their money before maturity.
These products can be particularly useful when funds are unlikely to be needed immediately, but there is still some uncertainty about when they may be required. They may also appeal to investors concerned about declining interest rates who want to secure a fixed return while retaining a measure of flexibility.
However, cashable and redeemable GICs are not necessarily the most suitable place to hold emergency savings or money that may be needed without notice. Withdrawal restrictions, waiting periods, and potential reductions in earned interest can make them less convenient than high-interest savings accounts.
For investors with a clearly defined savings timeline and sufficient accessible funds elsewhere, non-redeemable GICs generally provide higher guaranteed returns. Conversely, those who expect to make frequent withdrawals or need unrestricted access may find a competitive high-interest savings account more practical.
A combination of products can also be worth considering. Keeping short-term or emergency savings in an accessible account while allocating funds with longer investment horizons to GICs allows investors to balance liquidity with the potential for higher guaranteed returns.
Finding the Best GIC or Savings Rate in Canada
The best place to keep your savings depends on more than the highest available interest rate. Cashable and redeemable GICs, non-redeemable GICs, and high-interest savings accounts each offer different combinations of returns, accessibility, and certainty.
Current comparisons show that the leading nationally available one-year redeemable GIC offers the same advertised return as the most competitive everyday savings accounts, while longer-term flexible GICs provide a modest rate premium. Non-redeemable GICs continue to offer higher guaranteed returns for investors willing to commit their funds, although regional credit unions and specialized deposit products may provide competitive alternatives.
With rates and product conditions varying across financial institutions, comparing the available options can help Canadians make more informed decisions about where to hold their savings.
RateHunter brings together GIC and high-interest savings account rates from financial institutions across Canada, making it easier to compare products, review available terms, and identify competitive offers.
Explore the latest GIC rates, compare cashable and non-redeemable options, or review current high-interest savings account rates to find products that align with your financial goals.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a cashable GIC better than a high-interest savings account?
Neither product is universally better. Cashable GICs offer fixed interest rates with conditional early access, while high-interest savings accounts generally allow more flexible withdrawals but pay variable interest rates. The most suitable option depends on current rates, anticipated withdrawal needs, and the importance of guaranteed returns.
Do cashable GICs pay higher interest rates than savings accounts?
Not necessarily. As of November 15, 2026, the highest nationally available one-year cashable GIC pays 2.40%, while the leading redeemable GIC and everyday high-interest savings accounts offer 3.00%. Longer-term flexible GICs may offer higher rates, although withdrawal conditions and investment terms should be considered.
Can you withdraw money from a redeemable GIC before maturity?
Generally, redeemable GICs permit withdrawals before maturity, but the conditions vary by financial institution. Early redemption may result in reduced interest earnings, penalties, minimum holding periods, or restrictions on partial withdrawals. Reviewing these provisions is important before purchasing a GIC.
Are cashable GICs insured in Canada?
Eligible cashable GICs issued by CDIC member institutions may qualify for deposit insurance, subject to applicable coverage limits and requirements. Credit unions generally operate under provincial deposit protection frameworks, with coverage that varies by jurisdiction.
Should I choose a one-year or five-year GIC?
The appropriate term depends on when the funds may be needed and how long the investor wants to secure a particular interest rate. Longer-term GICs can provide greater certainty about returns, but they may also limit opportunities to benefit from higher rates that become available before maturity. Investors should consider their savings timeline, withdrawal requirements, and the differences in advertised rates before selecting a term.
Rates referenced in this article were checked against Ratehunter's data on the publication date shown above and may have changed since — the rate boards always carry the current numbers. See our editorial standards and advertiser disclosure.